To the right of the main street, on a short alley that looked like the moon, were the doors to Hell.
And since that was the name of the saloon, we jokingly would say things like «Let’s go to Hell» those afternoons when there was nothing else to do but lull the afternoon with a beer on hand and paly darts or «Come with us to Hell» to our cousins from the city or … «Why do you think I work for? To go to Hell, of course». To this joke, my grandmother, a respectable and gray haired woman on her 70s whom always went to mass, would raise an eyebrow and purse her lips in reprobation. Her small defect of a tumour like appendage on her right side of the lips trembled. One day, the dough was resting on the table waiting for my grandmother to finish a new table cloth’s embroidery and getting puffier when a ding dong came from the door. I wanted to scream, my nose was a leaking tap and my head was like a fluid fish bowl with my brain floating on it dead. But grandma can barely move around so I couldn’t help snorting when I saw her on her feet and opening the door to a couple of guys. Then she turned around and yelled towards my room: —Christian were going bar crawling tonight! Get the truck ready honey She laughed a lot when she realised I was there on the stairs, transfixed looking at the tiny tentacles around her mouth. Then she and her also tentacled friends came up to me and surrounded my shoulders with their arms. — Tonight we aren’t going to Hell. We’re going to all the Styx, Purgatory, Valhalla and Paradise boy…
Outside the chubby lavender villa, there was this reddish guy admiring the «On sale» board. He would press a cotton handkerchief on his nose from time to time until he wheezed like an old toy and entered the house.
Inside, an smell to old decaying money was beginning to stench. Enrico placed his hand on the stairs rail and reacted immediately. He had left his hand in a negative imprinted mark. He took off the handkerchief again and cleaned his hands.
Upstairs, there was this room with beautiful birds painted all over the walls and furniture. A tiny fat prune was looking at him with a lot of interest from the bed. —How do you find the house Mr. Gallo? —Big and well by the side of the highway. I can’t pay more than what I told you by the phone…Misses Loretta —That’s ok lad. Nobody is buying anyway. —May I ask why? —Once you start talking to the folks you’ll know. Just… No, never mind. Saint John’s wort on the garden will take care of it
A month later, that bed was gone and Misses Loretta would be living in the nearest town’s retirement house whilst what had once been her kitchen oozed bacon and crispy bread smells. Enrico had opened an italo-dutch restaurant. His Flammkuchen would attract lots of flies with cameras hanging from their necks… Until last week. He had no idea what had happened since everything was the same. The same garden… That had changed a little. He had needed space for culinary herbs and he had decided thus, to cut off some of the patches with Saint John’s wort. Besides, the pretty girl in the green apron by the gas station’s seven eleven, had liked sunflowers. She was a lovely creature of blue eyes and a name as blue as they were.
A week later, Azure called the police. Enrico had forgotten to call her for a whole week not to say the least, he had left her alone on their date! Worst, some tourists had complained they had gone to enjoy his famous flammkuchen.
The first thing the three policemen noticed was the sulphur smell. The whole house smelled like the devil. The second was the atmosphere. Inside, there was an aquarium of light. There were butterflies dancing or swimming in that light, gravitationless kingyos in a fish bowl. The three men jumped at the same time, with a better synchronization than any Korean band could ever achieve. At the edge of the stairs, Mr. Gallo looked at them, amused.
The only policeman without crows feet started to run towards him when the oldest senior, caught his arm.
—Are you all right sir? Someone reported you missing after a week of a closed restaurant — The youngest man couldn’t help asking. — Don’t you see he is alive and well — whispered the officer holding his arm and trying to drag him downstairs.
—Indeed, I’m fine. That bloody herb smells like heaven and I’m allergic to it. Get closer good men, I’d like to shake your hands to congratulate you in your good job. The thin young policeman tried to get up there, but the old man; brazenly resorted to grab his arm and run stairs down and out of the villa. The other one did the same. They ran until they were The youngest men in uniform protested by getting off the old one’s grip.
—What the heck is wrong with you two? —Didn’t you see his shadow? — asked the one who hadn’t participated as much as fleeing too. — ¡he had had horns and a tail! He sure made his fortune.
Matins. They woke up and it wasn’t there. The body wasn’t there anymore! Fray Gère looked up to the eyes of Fray Dejan who made one of those faces.
Fray Gère put his hand inside the coffin. Sometimes, when you think you have lost your quill sharpener, it appears exactly in the same pocket you might swear it was before you lost it. Mysteries of the devil, holy mother of god.
No, the coffin was still as empty as it seemed to him before. Fray Dejan didn’t say a word but made a gesture inviting Fray Gère to follow him.
They went out of the catacombs through a spiral staircase and exited at the roses garden. Roses were good for the black Death and masking smells… Fray Dejan showed him by pointing with a very bony finger, the tracks of a pair of horses. They loam was still wet with last night’s rain. Both fryers made the signal of the cross, fearing the body to be used for witchcraft.
Some kilometres away, I can’t really tell how many since it was really dark and it was difficult to see if the horse was well fed or not; two men in black fashionable velvet, went as fast as they could. Behind one of them, there was this big blanket wrapped bundle. It was expected to arrive on time to be buried in Flores
Hi. Here I am announcing I’m going to devote this month to the Drawlloween 2022. Just that, instead of some ink, I’ll be writing something (and forfeiting the rest of my duties by showing you how to write fiction). I hope they’re stories good enough to honour my favourite holiday. No, my favourite holiday isn’t Día de muertos. I find it kind off track to celebrate the return of a soul when I don’t believe in souls… Which doesn’t help me from loving the bread and the flowers of the time. Ah… I totally forgot yesterday we were already in October (and with it an acquaintance’s birthday).
Sí, el sábado pasado sucedió algo. Me alcanzó la procrastinación. Toda la semana anterior había estado subiendo entradas el día anterior a su aparición, como muy tarde, debido a asuntos climáticos. Pero era sorprendente verme traduciendo para el miércoles ya en sábado y leyendo sobre narratología ya en miércoles…. Cuando suelo dejar todo a la última hora. Así que la semana anterior a la anterior, todo iba como la seda… Hasta que esa semana anterior me dio por hacerme quack (pato). Y quedarme leyendo webtoon hasta horas muy tempranas del día. Pues el viernes… no pudo importarme menos que meterme en mi camita y dormir. Afortunadamente, como estuve de hormiguita anteriormente, había con que suplir la entrada del día. Me disculpo por dejar que la procrastinación calara.
Vale. Y eso sonó tan español que no me lo creo. Más bien debería decir algo como que esto no está chido. Y me desacredito como experta en cualquier cosa. Y es que hubo un párrafo… o dos. Lo confieso, no los conté, que no entendí lo más mínimo. Lo maravilloso es que no voy a escribir más del asunto porque lo interesante de la lectura de esta semana son las subfábulas.
Todo comienza con que Mieke Bal de pronto se preocupa porque describir las relaciones entre distintos tipos de fenómenos, causa un desequilibrio numérico entre actores y actantes[1]. Lo que no debería de ser raro porque si los actantes son las clases de actores que comparten una cualidad o característica; entonces, por lógica, habrá personajes (actores) que comparten o caen dentro de más de una clase. Después de todo, se pueden clasificar según el interés del que analiza de modo gramatical…
Número de actores por orientación de la fábula
Lo interesante aquí es ¿POR QUÉ ES IMPORTANTE LA EXISTENCIA DE UN DESEQUILIBRIO NUMÉRICO ENTRE ACTANTES Y ACTORES?
Mieke establece el número de actores presentes en la fábula en una relación proporcional a su orientación al exterior o interior del [personaje principal[2]] como determinantes para el número de actores presentes en la fábula.
A mayor orientación de la fábula hacia el mundo exterior [del personaje]; mayor es el número de actantes en la fábula. Y mientras más subjetivo se vuelve el mundo de la trama, menor es el número de actores…
Lo que resulta bastante sorprendente porque La metamorfosis de Kakfa, está toda escrita alrededor del interior de la mente de Gregorio y, por ende, no tiene más que un actor (sí recuerdo la historia). En contraposición, Lucky Live de Nöstlinger, tiene muchos personajes a pesar de su extensión, ya que es una historia sobre cómo afecta el exterior visible a las acciones de un chico de preparatoria que desea cambiar de “fuera” hacia “dentro”.
El antisujeto y el sujeto autónomo
Dentro de la fábula existe el sujeto o personaje principal, quién desea algo (llamado objeto del deseo) y los oponentes. Los oponentes se dedican a impedir que el sujeto logre su deseo, metiéndole la pata en algún momento de la trama…
¿Qué sucede si de repente aparece algún actor con una búsqueda independiente y propia de su deseo que entra en conflicto con la búsqueda del personaje principal?
Pues que ese es un antisujeto… Y algunos antisujetos, tienen su propia búsqueda y esa búsqueda no entra en conflicto de modo alguno con el deseo del personaje principal. A ese lo conocemos como sujeto autónomo. Si Pedro desea comerse un dragón y ya no quedan dragones mientras el príncipe Felipondio desea casarse con la ratoncita Juana secuestrada en el castillo del último dragón; Pedro pasa a ser un antisujeto. En cambio, si Pedro desea comerse el dragón y los dragones no tienen nada que ver ni con Felipondio ni con Juana, entonces Pedro es un sujeti autónomo.
Los sujetos autónomos y también los antisujetos pueden meterse en la trama principal y cambiar un poquito la balanza a favor o en contra de la búsqueda del primer sujeto (personaje principal). Ya sea por subordinación al deseo del personaje principal o sin subordinación; creando lasubfábula.
Subfábula
Es de esta manera, que los narratólogos han descubierto la trama secundaria. Los antisujetos o sujetos autónomos que llevan una parte de la trama sin aparente conexión con la trama principal corren su propia idea de cómo debe seguir una historia o fábula en lo que tú y yo llamaríamos trama secundaria o terciaria normalmente. Mieke observa que el uso de subfábulas puede contribuir a tornar más entretenida una fábula.
Concluyendo, si introducimos personajes cuyo deseo sea distinto del deseo del protagonista; podemos introducir a un personaje que afecte la trama, ayudando u oponiéndose al protagonista. Lo que resulta más entretenido aún que una fábula simple.
Lo que Mieke no nota es la conexión que debe existir entre el sujeto autónomo y la búsqueda del objeto de deseo del sujeto principal. Sin dicha conexión, la fábula se cae a pedazos pues pierde su coherencia. Esta conexión o concepto de la conexión entre la fábula y la subfábula, Robert McKee la llama “idea controladora”. Yo la llamo “eje temático”.
Una serie de televisión donde se puede apreciar fácilmente esto del eje temático es en The good doctor. Todos los episodios… casi todos, se basan en dos casos médicos que llegan al hospital Saint Bounaventure sin conexión aparente hasta que el desarrollo de la trama nos hace ver el eje temático o idea controladora que sirve como pegamento entre ambas historias. Además de que todo pasa en el mismo hospital. Obvi… ¿Lo topas[3]?
Pues topa el like, comenta y suscríbete. O no. Al fin la subfábula aquí, es que aún no tengo muchos comentarios y eso podría usarse como ambientación para un fallo épico. Fallar no es algo raro. Sucede.
[2] En este caso el uso de los corchetes, como en las tablillas cuneiformes, denota un concepto que no está pero sustituyo con lo que creo que debe ir allí, en comparación y asimilación de lo que he estado leyendo hasta ahora.
If you aren’t younger than me, you know what I’m talking about. DVDs divide the content of a movie in scenes at the menu (almost always). Sometimes with the super inflated number of none the less than 40 scenes and some others, with less than 25. Such a happening, gives us the feeling of understanding what a scene is without a need for me to define them. We can even think examples…almost for certain.
However… whenever we go to the writing domains, the concept of scene becomes more complicated. It’s so difficult to grab it by the hair. How to know where to start it and where to end it? How many scenes are a good number of scenes and how many are too much or too little?
On sight of this, I’ve got no other than doing the tough and disagreeable job of defining a word before getting its LINE…. Or getting myself even more confused than before.
Scene
Ours… well mine (since nobody else uses it here) is a second hand Webster from 1977 and it says:
Scene. (sēn) [<Gr. skēnē, stage]
1. the stage where an event occurs 2. the setting of a play, story, etc. 3. a division of a play , usually part of an act 4. a unit of action in a motion picture, story, etc. 5. same as scenery (sense 1) 6.a view of people and places 7. a display of strong feeling [to make a scene] 8. [Colloq.] the locale for a specified activity
Which seems a bit lacking, in comparison to my banqueted Larousse (prior 1970 probably). My loyal Larousse includes:
Suceso considerado como un espectáculo digno de atención: una escena conmovedora. / Something considered as a spectacle worth mentioning: a lovely scene
And before I go on, another word jumps out to out attention: ACT. What is an act?
Act. (akt) n. [<agree, to do] 1. a thing done 2. a doing 3. a law 4. a main division of a drama or opera….
Which again, lacks something somehow:
Hecho heroico. /Heroic deed
Robert McKee
Opposing the dictionary, Robert McKee in “The script. Story”, defines a scene as“an action happens through a conflict in a time and space more or less continuous; that changes one of the values of the character’s life in a perceptible way. In an ideal situation, each scene becomes a NARRATIVE EVENT”
This man leaves me astounded. According to whom do the values change? From the point of view of the character, the villain, my own or the possible reader? A conflict per scene? What is a narrative event?
Sarah Domet
Sarah Domet in ’90 days to your novel’doesn’t even try to. Of course, she writes novels and isn’t teaching how to write movie scripts. She gives us examples, but goes to say that no author is able to define a scene. Oh, but she does stablish a scene as an unity with its own intro, climax and ending. She says it like this[1]:
<<Think of your favorite movie. Or better yet, your favorite book. What was your favorite part?>
Here she names some parts of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, The Lovely Bones, Uncle
Tom’s Cabin, Braveheart and Spider-Man
<<All these “parts” mentioned above are actually just a single scene from each of these works. But what is a scene? How does one define it? Scene writing is often difficult to discuss — for both new and seasoned writers — because a scene combines all elements of fiction in harmony with one another. It isn’t just one aspect of craft — it’s all of them put together, artfully and thoughtfully, to achieve the same kind of balance you hope for in that extravagant dish you prepare for your dinner guests. And how much of any single element (dialogue, setting, description, etc.) you need is going to depend on the particular purpose of the scene within the larger scope of your novel.
Did you get anything from all this defining?! Not even older (as in experienced) writers can define it. But it seems so worthy, it seems there can’t be plot without scenes.
I’m not really sure if Eisnten said it really but it is said he said: if you can explain something to your grandmother, then you understand it… NOT THAT THERE ARE ACTUALLY PEOPLE WHO CAN EXPLAIN QUANTUM MECHANICS. And yet, quarks do exist…
Like it or not, comment or not, subscribe or not. This is the unknown dimension of the narrative particles…
TO BE CONTINUED…
[1] Quotation or total copy-paste. As you might see it.
En realidad, en mi opinión, la realidad o la verdad es más extraña no porque no se ciña a las posibilidades. Es una simple cuestión de escala. La realidad maneja muchas más variables, muchas desconocidas. La ficción, maneja posibilidades de aquello que se conoce. Tal vez, esa sea la diferencia…
¡Hola! Hoy les traigo un enlace a una autora argentina. Si nunca has oído hablar de ella, pues nada, acabas de leer que existe. Y como, a veces, es mejor el vídeo que la perorata… Aquí está.
Stubbornly (and only since I didn’t really get it and I’m particularly talented at being bigheaded), is it that I’ll try to explain a really basic classification of narrative scenes. According to Sarah Domet in “90 days to your novel”.
Narrative scenes internal and external
Were this to have any more clasification, then I’d have to sit down to read from Wednesday and write on Fridays. However, there are only two.
The things that happen in our head or internal scenes, are exactly that. The existence’s quarrel; among those of sound mind surrounded by all the ones wanting to pretend to be responsible: the how much I hate the neighbour’s drapes; the lovely behind of the guy in the gas station.
He casual meeting or the external scene. Yep. Encounters between our dear character and the rest of the population inhabiting our fantasy world, that require more action than hating some cloth or just admiring an anatomy model. If the character goes to the gym, they talk to their coach. Greets the receptionist at the dentist (whilst trembling inside). Buys the bread looking at the sugar bread loaves of the cashier. Smiles to the cute doggy they cross with, in the street. Interaction with the outside and if not there (according to Domet) can turn our world into a bore.
In her opinion[1], good stories are populated of these casual meetings in different shapes and arrangements… Butm if I remember it well, Teresa (from The unbearable lightness of the being) doesn’t have much interaction to be mentioned, with other characters. Much less the girl in The North China Lover. Of course, these stories are part of the LITERATURE in ways Agatha Christie doesn’t. That… that takes us to Miss Marple. Miss Marple is always remembering what he or shesaid and talks pretty much to eveeeeerybody. And maybe such is the charm of these kind of stories. Not many people refrain themselves from solving a Christie’s puzzle.
And if what you need is a more modern example, Yumi’s cells by Donggeon Lee, is a lovely webtoon where to see this internal/external or zoom in/zoom out scene game. The thoughts of the main character, Yumi; are displayed on stage by the cell of love, hunger, emotional, good manners, history, naughty (the pervert one).
Everything coming through her head is an interaction game between these tiny characters. So, at least for the case, the external scenes show Yumi as an entity who displays what happens outside, either on her own or with other characters.
Taking into account, Ronald B. Tobias (the one of the “20 master plots”) likes explaining plots by using movies as examples —besides books— (take little to SEE what the heck he is talking about), I think comics are a very good source of knowledge. It is between movies, where you see what’s coming on and it is almost impossible to narrate telling, and the novel; where there is a bunch of text and you can only trust the words.
Complicate?
The example makes it a little more palatable, doesn’t it?
Like, subscribe, leave a comment instead having an internal scene where you like this nonsense and… be happy.
[1] She uses Charles Dickens as an example since he wrote lots of characters, “some fairly
insignificant, but fun to meet.” Any Dickens expert out there? I only read Christmas Carol and didn’t like much of it… so I barely remember it.
«Las dos categorías comentadas hasta ahora se encuentran directamente vinculadas al objeto, que lo es tanto de deseo como de comunicación. Ambas relaciones son necesarias para el desarrollo de la fábula. Pero una fábula que se basara sólo en estas dos relaciones acabaría muy pronto: el sujeto quiere algo, y lo logra o no. Normalmente el proceso no es tan sencillo.»
Mieke Bal. Teoría de la narrativa, introducción a la narratología.
Vaya, vaya. Alguien que revisa textos usando la gramática como medida, se acaba de dar cuenta que hace falta algo más que el deseo del personaje. Aparte de eso, comienzan a aparecer los Totos, Mushues[1] y demás aliados por el camino. Una tercera relación entre los sujetos de la fábula. Y yo sigo pensando que la fábula es dónde sale el zorro y la liebre…
En fin, que gramaticalmente; los actantes (una clase de actores con una relación idéntica en el aspecto de intención teleológico[2]) son complementos adverbiales de la oración… Mocos. ¿¡Tú sabes que es un complemento adverbial?!
¿Ni idea? Bueno, en eso estamos juntos. Lo googlearé por ti.
COMPLEMENTO DEL ADVERBIO
Complemento del adverbio es el sintagma preposicional cuya función es completar informativamente el significado que reclama un adverbio que funciona como núcleo de un sintagma adverbial[3]….
OK. Eso fue como intentar mirar una araña destripada como una araña. Tal vez lo único que nos dice que es una araña son las patitas del ejemplo: Lejos de casa. Pero… esto todavía no es la araña del subtítulo. Veamos este otro:
Los complementos adverbiales pueden ser distintos tipos de adverbios, aunque son más frecuentes los adverbios de tiempo (ayer, ahora) y de lugar (allí, aquí) en forma aclaratoria. Menos frecuentes serán en los adjetivos que tienen una significación completa por sí mismos, como los de afirmación (sí), negación (no, ni) o de duda[4].
Supongo que esa fue una experiencia mucho mejor en nuestro papel taxidermista. Así que, de acuerdo. Los ayudantes y oponentes son los complementos adverbiales de una oración y se relacionan con el objeto a través de preposiciones. ¿Y? ¿No son lo mismo que los personajes dador y receptor de la entrada anterior?
DIFERENCIAS ENTRE DADORES Y AYUDANTES
No. No son iguales. Para empezar, el dador es por lo regular sólo uno (por lo regular las encarnaciones no toman múltiples cuerpos) ; mientras que hay muchos ayudantes. Estos muchos ayudantes, por ser muchos, prestan ayuda de una forma parcial. A diferencia de los dadores, que poseen control sobre casi todo (no diré todo como Mieke, porque no controlan el “libre albedrío”). Pueden abandonar el decorado y entrar en escena para robársela momentáneamente al personaje/actor principal y por lo mismo; tienen un o muchos momentos de narración para ellos solos.
Es decir, que en realidad esto del ayudante y el oponente son los múltiples personajes de los que llenada Dickens sus novelas[5] y son los personajes que suelen gustarnos un montón; como los villanos y los patiños.
Aunque no siempre se trata de personajes. Pueden ser simples características del personaje o circunstancias circunstanciales… Cuando uno confían en análisis gramáticales para encontrar las fuerzas que habitan una historia, lo más probable es que termine con algo cierto pero también muy extraño.
¿Recuerdas a Virginia? Bueno, el duque de Ormuz visita a la señorita Rosina porque Rosina es su media hermana ilegítima[6]. Se llevaban muy bien cuando niños pero, al morir el padre; la madre del duque la expulsa de la casa celosa. El duque no puede decirle nada a Virginia porque Rosina sería víctima del ataque de la duquesa viuda, siempre alerta para deshacerse de ella.
Esto llevado al análisis gramatical nos dice que un oponente no personajeado (que no es un personaje) del duque de Ormuz es su propio silencio. Mientras que la madre del duque es un personaje oponente porque sí es personaje y, al oponerse a Rosina, se interpone entre el duque y Virginia.
Y como consecuencia, esta subdivisión de actores, nos puede ayudar a tomar en cuenta todos los pros del personaje a favor de que obtenga su deseo (incluyendo a los personajes que ayudarán en pequeñas dosis) y los contras de que lo logre a través de su comportamiento.
¿Cómo usar esta subdivisión de actores en el texto narrativo? (o cualquier narración en general)
Vamos a usarla como una planeación de ruta de qué circunstancias motivan los desastres que le acontecen al personaje debido a su personalidad o propiedades (qué en sí del personaje, lo mete en un lío). Y a quién vamos a plantar ahí, en la ruta, como guía de turistas que le dé indicaciones al personaje de cómo llegar a donde quiere ir (obtener el objeto de su deseo)
El mapa de ruta que voy a mostrarte hoy con esta entrada; incluye darle like (si estás leyendo en Facebook puedes dar like en Facebook), suscribirte (si todavía no lo has hecho) y comentar. Tal vez no sea mucho, pero eso me ayuda un montón a no pensar en la inutilidad de escribir estas chorradas. ¿Me ayudas?
Look out! Here I see the ship of cliché coming in the contemplative scene… It has sails all directed to East and here I lose the joke since I perfectly know what east means but didn’t what levante meant.
The fresh breeze and a blue sky, a velvet kiss on your lips I tell. It rains you poor soul and she has left.
“Not always is the cliché a bad stuff”: the contemplative scene
When the host of “This is opera” speaks about Turandot and clichés, he mentions the ample possibilities of clichés as instantaneous contemplative scenes. Something akin to the chicken broth in a dice. That thingie that makes food tastier without the hour or hours of boiling chicken to get some thick and rich broth. No greater explanations or bureaucracies: The morning shimmered to the sun and he smile to his own reflect.
It all depends on how we help the cliché to work out with intentionality and direction or we stablish our “own” to contemplate or give voice to what should be hidden as part of the background since, it is the background.
In Yumi’s Cells[1]; Donggeon Lee employs a rock band called “The endorphines” to tell us how well Yumi fells given the circumstances[2].
Camilleri —my fetish writer since he breaks the rules by following them — says things like this in the open: the sky would rumble and Montalbano, who changes mood with the weather, would sparkle as well. Then us sparkle with the detective withour further ado of an explanation.
Thereafter there are the emotional scenes
In Conceal don’t feel: how to write fiction without naming feelings and sequel, I mention how to speak of feelings or emotions without summoning them directly but… It seems to me, we can really go and skip the physical repercussions to just say whatever the character is feeling. That gives an action feeling to something that doesn’t require as much contemplative description.
Are you writing romance? Of course you need better emotional scenes, where to describe physically the feelings of the ML/FL or main or whatever you’d like to call the character. This is what portrays the plot greatly.
In inner dialogue or monologue we lose ourselves in the character’s mind
It is not as if these scenes aren’t interesting. Some novels or tales are nothing but nonsense happening in a character’s mind. To Sarah Domet, advocate of modern scenes, they are only worth if I say I won’t go around beating the bush (I say I think) and after that; I tell you the newest exploit of the Liverpool as a great football team where heros are taken out of rough diamonds, without the least monetary patronage that counts as buying a championship. (I did something totally different).
The biggest the symbolism joining what is said, the greater the impact of the monologue in the plot further ahead in the game.
He finally signed the life insurance. He was absolutely convinced of her being a moron who might end up in the streets were he to suffer an accident. She said that the departing taxes wouldn’t be reduced by paying the prime and that they were young and would be together for many years to come. What would she know of taxesif she didn’t work! Besides, he didn’t want the child to suffer any neglect due to Shirley working. Probably as maid or housekeeper since she didn’t know anything else that cleaning and cooking.
In this plot idea, the life insurance could embody the financial genius of the woman who zas!, murders the man telling this to us. By adding 60% of ethanol to the petrol in his car to abandon the child thereafter in a cloister or some other place alike.
She answered: dialogue scenes
Sarah Domet never mentions them but this one that Chuck Wendig (and my mother) consider core of the plot, the dialogue scenes.
And…yep. There are very good plots without dialogue[3]. It is more than enough to read the black bean in the rice which has inspired one or two BL mangas: Daddy long legs by Jane Webster. I might have never read it if it hadn’t been for that reason. Used as background, almost unaltered (turn the girl into a boy and the handsome man into a school principal or anything else[4]) or as an excuse to have it adapted to shoujo manga; it is such a delicious one.
Why? It is a plot told thorugh letters! Dialogue, blinds us by abscence. It is all inner monologue and narrative description. And still, it conquered mangakas and filmmakers. No, my mother would never read it.
Consequently, the dialogue scenes can work out our problems with the “show, don’t tell”. If you have read The silence of the lambs by Thomas Harris you might remember the “»much obliged m’am» of Starling. This, added to her cheap shoes[5], tell tale her as a mere country bumpkin in Hannibal’s eyes. Dialogue, well encased —long difficult words, the right grammar or badly built phrases — together with interaction or betrayal between what is said and done, can introduce us to the character’s psyque.
According to Domet, dialogue rushes the rhythm as we’d like to know what is said later. I call it the window gossiper effect by the gossiper we all have inside. Speaking of rushing things, we have the action scenes.
Scene 4, take 2: action scenes
The action scenes are scenes to take the plot forward —don’t ask, I didn’t get this either. Where is forward according to what? — This is the type of scene happens when a character feels like pushing down the red button labeled “DON’T PUSH”. We all know that equals disaster. And disaster equals plot. It ain’t really relevant if they reflect they shouldn’t have touched the button or they didn’t get a right reading of Tarot’s cards. Domet explains it as a REACTION to the events. And to this case, she has a very interesting advice… to learn Latin. Yeah, since to start scenes a media res requires lots of training. To begin with, to become aware of what a media res means…
Media res means to begin an scene in the middle of the action by describing a lot what is seen, felt, saw and tasted by the character to offer the feeling of things happening. It is this feeling which makes us feel like there’s action and it can be stretched until tension is in the air.
On the other side, another good advice is to begin from the beginning. Ah, writing/designing is difficult. Contradictory. And awesome.
Such is the dilemma: drama scenes
Are drama scenes simply action scenes but slower? No. If I were to compare them to cooking; a drama scene is a simply well done stew with action, discovery and emotion to the same share. All right, the gastronomical example might not work since I’m not calling a particular dish: mole de olla. Meat broth with diced potato, carrots, corn and guajillo chili… (if casually you have no idea what that is). A really balanced scene to say so.
And since I’m commenting a classification by Sarah Domet, I gotta mention she uses The great Gatsby as example. Which gets me into lots of hubble. One, I read the book in Spanish so I might have missed a lot of subtle stuff. Two, I didn’t love the book as much as she loved it. I don’t think it is genial. Three, I’m still far from analyzing things at the first reading.
However, if I understood anything, it seems a drama scene is very similar to what happens to Ana Karenina in …you seriously don’t know? No prob, the title is homonymous to the character. Ana realizes she can’t go on living as she is and then she throws herself to the train tracks. Discovery: life can’t go on as such. Emotion: guilt and over anything, desperation. Action: to throw herself into the tracks.
Fuuu, sure we can break our horns with these classifications. I realize I should have attacked first the problem of defyining an scene. What I might do will be keeping the inner and external scenes for future references. I believe dialogue and drama are more like result of how these two last types of scene are managed, than scenes by their own right.
You? Do you know instinctively what an scene it and won’t need definitions or would you have preferred to start there?
Like, subscribe, comment. Or go and dramatize saying this blog is pure nonsense. Anything is fine.
[1] To good of a webtoon to not keeping using it as example.
[2] Anyone can tell the energy in the environment of a rock concert and over it, you get the frustation if it gets cancelled in the middle.
[3] My mother might not like those but that doesn’t mean it is impossible.
Sí, vamos a escribir ficción usando un poco el otro idioma. Ese del otro escritor que nadie nombra por ahí como grandioso[1]. Y no es que haya sido idea de Mieke o mía. Es debido a las circunstancias en las que el deseo del personaje no basta para lograr lo que desea; que a un sujeto llamado Greimas (no pregunten, no tengo idea, tal vez más adelante y por el momento no importa quién era…bueno ahí el enlace de Wikipedia); se le hayan ocurrido estos nombres.
Así que, recapitulemos en mor de la claridad.
Los personajes (oops, actores), desean cosas. Pero desear solito no los lleva a obtener lo que quieren[2]. Siempre hay “poderes” externos que les estorban y por lo tanto; es a través de esta relación entre el actor y lo que se le mete en el camino que existe una segunda clasificación de actantes (relaciones entre actores).
Dador y destinatario
O como los llama Greimas: destinateur y destinataire. Nombres que nos hacen pensar en esta suerte de actividad que involucra papel y tinta y sellos postales y carteros. Pero no.
Incluso podríamos confundirlos con estos otros actores que en la narración, actúan como sidekicks o mascotas de las princesas Disney…. Y otra vez no.
Si traducimos destinateur porremitente, tenemos una relación entre ambos que implica una participación activa donde el “dador” le entrega al actor; aquello que va a ayudarlo a resolver el problema de su deseo. Y voy a romper el número mágico porque Mieke dice que no es así como sucede (tercera negación de tú deseo, querida lectora o querido lector). Si bien, sí es el dador el que proporcionará la herramienta o el objeto de deseo, no se trata de una persona común y corriente.
Se trata de una ABSTRACCIÓN. Esta abstracción puede ser la sociedad, el destino o el tiempo. Es decir, una encarnación. Sí, como Bill Puerta. Una representación antropomórfica, bastante habitual en los cuentos de hadas y que tiene que ver con elementos un tanto mágicos del tipo deus ex machina y que encontramos menos y menos en la ficción conforme mejoramos las técnicas narrativas.
Como ejemplo, podemos citar la historia donde el hada madrina (destino), otorga el vestido y la movilidad para asistir al baile; logrando así que la protagonista adquiera lo que desea.
En el análisis de textos narrativos
El sujeto y/o el dador (no siempre son equivalentes) tienen una actividad gramatical mucho más activa que la del objeto/destinatario. ¿Confuso? Sí.
Hasta que miramos el ejemplo que propone Mieke y que voy a decorar o mejorar con técnicas narrativas. (Para que esta entrada no sea una réplica total de lo que dice Mieke).
Era la noche callada y Virginia, que nunca le guardaba secretos al duque de Ormuz, prefirió emular a la noche. No abriría la boca hasta que el duque dejara de visitar a la señorita Rosina[3].
Aquí nuestro sujeto es el duque de Ormuz porque debe haber preguntado algo (incluso si no lo leemos). Virginia es el dador. Sólo que en vez de dar, niega (los dadores pueden también negar cosas). Le niega la respuesta al duque. En la oración siguiente, es el duque el que se convierte en dador. El deseo de Virginia es que deje de visitar a la señorita Rosina. Por lo que el duque, al darle gusto o no, se convierte en el dador.
Esta relación entre personajes (o actante) es como un preámbulo al descubrimiento del conflicto como algo que debe escalarse. Greimas lo define con base en la relación entre actores (personajes). Mientras que, los gurús de la escritura creativa[4]lo proponen como una serie de impedimentos al deseo del personaje (sin importar de donde provengan).
Sí el personaje tiene el agua hasta el cuello, ¿por qué no hacer que casi se ahogue?
Para escribir con destinataire y destinateur, hay que pensar en la dinámicade la relación entre los diferentes personajes.Cuándo y cómo estas interacciones van a darle al personaje principal lo que desea y, si este acto va a joderle la existencia y como escalará o no, el conflicto a niveles casi imposibles de resolver.
Como técnica (sí es que se le puede llamar así), se puede ver mucho en el manga (y los dramas chinos). Acciones que generan muchos malentendidos y que en general, forman parte del repertorio cliché de la narrativa asiática romántica pero que no encontrábamos tan marcados en occidente.
¿Puras chorradas? Sí. ¿Te gustó? Sí, porque lo leíste. O no, en cuyo caso te recomiendo que hables mal de mí. Así que, dale like, comparte, suscríbete. Aquí no hay invasión de newsletters en tu correo electrónico. Sólo lo que te interese leer.
[1] Honoré de Balzac. A quién no he leído. Se disputa el título con Víctor Hugo, a quién sí he leído.
[2] Extraño que esta sea la similitud más cercana a lo que sucede en el mundo real de entre todas las similitudes y también donde las similitudes se terminan. Son más comunes las historias con finales satisfactorios que las vidas humanas con finales satisfactorios.